Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

20
  • A. H. Pitz US 2370
  • Adventurer US 107174
  • Bayline Park Wreck
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • City of St. Joseph (City of Chicago) US 126627
  • Col. Ellsworth (c1850)
  • E. Cohen
  • Emerald (1862)
  • Record 14974
  • Record 2352
  • Record 2359
  • Record 2376
  • Record 3954
  • Record 4379
  • Record 4533
  • Record 7880
  • Swansea US 115165
  • Tri-County Corridor Wreck
  • Unknown Shipwreck
  • Wayne US 80881

Ashore

11
  • Altadoc (Lake Shore) C 116577
  • Bessie Barwick
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • Chenango US 4335
  • City Of Bangor US 127131
  • Coaster (1848)
  • George (George Murray)
  • Saturn
  • T. M. Bradley US 145172
  • Union US 25048
  • W.W. Arnold US 26166

Burnt at Dock

8
  • A.F. Bartlett US 105130
  • Amethyst US 1712
  • City Of Winnipeg (Annie L. Craig)
  • Sailor Boy US 116393
  • Swansea US 115165
  • Thomas Quayle US 24159
  • Thomas W. Palmer (Samoa) US 145229
  • Winslow US 26174

Collision

6
  • Huronton (Huron US 96425) C 141664
  • John B. Cowle
  • John Mitchell
  • Onoko US 155048
  • Thomas Wilson (1892)
  • Two Katies (Two Kates) US 24980

Destroyed at (Dock, Breakwater, Harbour)

1
  • Algonquin (1839)

Dismantled/Dynamited/Scrapped in Place

2
  • City Of Bangor US 127131
  • Lafayette

Fire

22
  • A.F. Bartlett (1871)
  • Alice Vivian US 30240
  • Amethyst US 1712
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Bob Anderson 1862
  • Carlotta US 105834 (Adrienne, Thora)
  • City Of Ashland US 126240
  • City Of Winnipeg (Annie L. Craig)
  • Hunter US 95471
  • Ira Chaffee US 12131
  • Queen City US 20519
  • Queen of the Lakes US 20508
  • SS Cumberland (1871)
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • T. M. Bradley US 145172
  • Tom Dowling US 24988
  • Traveler (1852)
  • Union US 25083
  • V. Swain US 25888
  • Winslow US 26174
  • Wood Island US 206510 (Lyle D.)
  • Yosemite 27541

Located but Unidentified

4
  • Mission Springs (Unidentifed)
  • Record 3343
  • Record 4379
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)

Lost (Still Missing)

2
  • Convair F-106 Delta Dart
  • F-106 Delta Dart

Pounded to Pieces

7
  • Allegheny (1873)
  • Charles J. Kershaw (Kershaw)
  • City Of Superior
  • Convair F-106 Delta Dart
  • John Jacob Astor (1835)
  • Laura Bell
  • W.W. Arnold US 26166

Scuttled

6
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Green River C 138863 (Gogebic)
  • Record 4380
  • Record 4381
  • Steven Selvick (Lorian, Cabot)
  • U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Mesquite

Storm

12
  • A.A. Parker (1884) (Kasota)
  • Arbutus C 92642
  • Atlanta US 106746
  • Cleveland Pre-1852
  • E.T. Carrington US 135211
  • Henry B. Smith (1906)
  • J.L. Beckwith (James L. Beckwith)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • P. S. Marsh
  • Queen City(1855)
  • Sir Trevor Dawson(William C. Moreland)
  • Sunbeam (1861)

Stranded/Grounded

31
  • Algoma 1883
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Chenango US 4335
  • Chicago US 127590
  • City of Montreal
  • Colorado US 4267
  • E. Cohen
  • Elma US 8895
  • Emperor C 126654
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Gale Staples (Caledonia)
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • Hesper
  • Hunter US 95471
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • Kiowa (1920)
  • Lafayette
  • M.M. Drake US 91485
  • Manhattan (1867)
  • Monarch C 96834
  • Panama (John Craig)
  • Pasadena US 150465
  • Queen City(1855)
  • Samuel H. Foster US 115150
  • Sitka
  • Starucca US 115381
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • Tioga US 145405
  • Transport US 145211
  • You Tell US 656020

Sunk/Foundered

44
  • A.A. Parker (1884) (Kasota)
  • America US 107357
  • Arbutus C 92642
  • Arlington (Glencadam, F.P. Jones) C 138210
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Brandon C 92535
  • Cerisoles (1918)
  • Chicago US 127590
  • Chippewa (1837)
  • City Of Ashland US 126240
  • Cleveland Pre-1852
  • Comet US 5683
  • Comrade US 34132
  • Frank W. Wheeler US 120577
  • Fred B. Hall US 120757
  • Glenlyon (William H. Gratwick, Minnekahtha)
  • Henry Chisholm US 95610
  • Henry Steinbrenner
  • Hudson US 95953
  • John B. Cowle
  • John H. Drake US 12757
  • John M. Hutchinson US 75597
  • John M. Osborne (1882)
  • Jupiter
  • Langham (Tom Adams)
  • Leviathan
  • Myron (1888)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Niagara US 18714
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Pacific
  • Panther C 138004
  • Pearl B Campbell US 150296
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Smith Mare
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Southwest US 22359
  • Sunbeam (1861)
  • T.H. Camp US 147127
  • Urada 25243
  • W.T. Chappell US 80642
  • Yosemite 27541
  • Zillah (Edward Smith)

Wreck (Verified)

45
  • A. H. Pitz US 2370
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Bigler (J. Bigler, John Bigler)
  • Carlotta US 105834 (Adrienne, Thora)
  • Cerisoles (1918)
  • City of St. Joseph (City of Chicago) US 126627
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Frank W. Wheeler US 120577
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • J.L. Beckwith (James L. Beckwith)
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • Langham (Tom Adams)
  • Mission Springs (Unidentifed)
  • Monarch C 96834
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Panama (John Craig)
  • Panther C 138004
  • Peninsula
  • Record 2352
  • Record 2359
  • Record 3343
  • Record 3954
  • Record 4379
  • Record 4380
  • Record 4381
  • Record 4533
  • Record 6312
  • Record 7880
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Sir Trevor Dawson(William C. Moreland)
  • Sitka
  • Smith Moore (1880)
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Starucca US 115381
  • Steven Selvick (Lorian, Cabot)
  • Superior (1845)
  • Superior Mentor US 91378
  • Thomas Wilson (1892)
  • Tioga US 145405
  • Traveler (1852)
  • U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Mesquite
  • Urada 25243
  • You Tell US 656020

Wrecked

6
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Colorado US 4267
  • D.M. Clemson (1903)
  • J.W. Bennett
  • Myron (1888)
  • Samuel H. Foster US 115150
  • Home
  • Docs
  • American Superior
  • Pounded to Pieces
  • Allegheny (1873)

Shipwreck Report: Allegheny

Identification & Site Information

  • Wreck Name: Allegheny
  • Vessel Type: Wooden Three-Masted Schooner-Barge
  • Build Date: 1873
  • Builder: W.W. Loomis, Erie, Pennsylvania
  • Dimensions:Length: 187 feet (57 meters) Beam: 33 feet (10 meters) Depth: 13 feet (4 meters)
  • Gross Tonnage: 689 tons
  • Net Tonnage: 599 tons
  • Final Disposition Date: June 6, 1913
  • Location of Wreck: Near Vermilion Point, Lake Superior, Michigan
  • Coordinates: Exact location not documented; near lifesaving station at Vermilion Point
  • Depth at Wreck Site: Not specified
  • Condition: Vessel broke apart in a storm; remains scattered

Vessel Type Description

The Allegheny was a three-masted wooden Schooner-Barge, a vessel type commonly used in the 19th and early 20th centuries for transporting bulk cargoes like lumber. Designed to operate under tow by steamers, Schooner-barges were economical and robust, capable of carrying heavy loads across the Great Lakes. The Allegheny’s three masts allowed for auxiliary sail power, providing added stability and propulsion in emergencies.

History

The Allegheny was launched in 1873 in Erie, Pennsylvania, and operated for 40 years, primarily transporting lumber across the Great Lakes. Owned by J. Dunseith and based in Toledo, Ohio, the vessel played an essential role in supporting the booming lumber industry, which relied on maritime transport to meet regional demand.

Final Voyage and Loss

On June 6, 1913, the Allegheny was part of a tow led by the Steamer M.T. Greene, traveling through Lake Superior. The vessel carried a cargo of lumber when it encountered a severe storm near Vermilion Point, Michigan. Dense fog and gale-force winds caused the Towline to break, leaving the Allegheny adrift in increasingly rough conditions.

Stranded on a bar in front of the Vermilion Point Lifesaving Station, the Allegheny was subjected to relentless waves and ultimately broke apart. Of the six crew members aboard, five were rescued by the lifesaving station’s surf men, but one crew member tragically perished.

Final Disposition

The Allegheny was declared a Total Loss, with the Hull breaking apart under the storm’s force. The wreck was not salvaged and is presumed scattered near Vermilion Point. No official recovery operations were undertaken, and the remains of the vessel have not been extensively documented.

Environmental and Historical Impact

The wreck of the Allegheny is a poignant reminder of the dangers faced by maritime vessels navigating the Great Lakes. The incident underscores the importance of the lifesaving services operating along these waters, which saved countless lives during this hazardous period of Great Lakes commerce.

Current Condition & Accessibility

The wreck’s remains are deteriorated and scattered on the lake bed near Vermilion Point, making it a challenging site for exploration. The area is significant for divers and historians interested in the region’s maritime heritage.

Resources & Links

  • Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Comprehensive database of Great Lakes vessels and shipwrecks.
  • David Swayze Shipwreck File: Archival records of the Allegheny and other wrecks.

Conclusion

The Allegheny is emblematic of the Schooner-Barge era, a period when Great Lakes shipping was a cornerstone of regional commerce. Its loss during a storm highlights the perils faced by sailors and the critical role of lifesaving services. Though its remains lie largely forgotten, the Allegheny’s story endures as a chapter in the Maritime History of the Great Lakes.

Tags #ShipwreckReport #GreatLakes #LakeSuperior #MaritimeHistory #SchoonerBarge #LumberTrade #VermilionPoint #HistoricShipwrecks #Allegheny

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress