Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

19
  • Alton US 203057
  • Antares US 366
  • Badger C 138576
  • Bay City 1853
  • Britannia (1860)
  • Chicago (1835)
  • Coast Pilot 6
  • Hamilton J. Mills (1881)
  • Mautenee
  • Record 1615
  • Record H9889/80
  • Record LS 1778/40
  • Record LS1777/40
  • Record LS1778/40
  • Relief (1855)
  • Saint Lawrence US 22348
  • The Cleveland Barge
  • Thomas H. Howland US 24978
  • Young America US 27508

Ashore

15
  • Abbey (Abby)
  • Algerine (Algerian)
  • American Eagle US 570
  • Bay Trader
  • City Of Cleveland (1857)
  • Dunkirk (1823)
  • Exchange US 7315
  • Frontenac (1678)
  • H.F. Merry (1838)
  • Harmon A. Chamberlin (H.A. Chamberlin) US 42561
  • King Fisher (1867)
  • Transfer US 145486
  • Transport (1858)
  • Uncle Tom US 25040
  • USS Chippewa

Burnt at Dock

10
  • Adventure US 105567
  • Alvah S. Chisholm Jr US 107557
  • Bunker Hill (1835)
  • Chicago (1842)
  • City Of Buffalo (1857)
  • Cleveland (1837)
  • Hendrik Hudson (1846)
  • Two Sisters (Twin Sisters) US 212527
  • United States (1835)
  • Warnick US 145222 (T.M. Moore)

Collision

16
  • Advance
  • Armenia US 107219
  • Ashtabula (1906)
  • Atlantic 1833
  • Brunswick US 3148
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Caroline A. Bemis
  • Chesapeake (1838)
  • E.P. Ryerse US 7317
  • George Worthington US 10223
  • M.P. Barkalow US 90277
  • Sciota (1848)
  • Specular US 115876
  • Tashmoo US 145843
  • U.S. 104 US 167719
  • Wisconsin (1838)

Destroyed at (Dock, Breakwater, Harbour)

5
  • Constitution
  • Constitution (1837)
  • Eagle US 392
  • Henry Clay 1825
  • James F. Cahill US 165740

Dismantled/Dynamited/Scrapped in Place

8
  • Ashtabula (1906)
  • Charles B. Packard (Elfin-Mere)
  • City Of Buffalo US 127132
  • Dove US 6512
  • Grand Traverse US 91129
  • H.G. Cleveland
  • John J. Barlum (1890)
  • M.L. Canfield (Mary Lydia)

Explosion (Boiler, Gas, Dynamite)

1
  • Susan A. Clark US 22280

Fire

30
  • Annie Laurie US 105476
  • Arbutus US 206473
  • Bay Coal(Industry 1848?)
  • Bunker Hill (1835)
  • C.H. Plummer US 126494
  • Chas. A. Trinter US 206047
  • City Of Buffalo US 127132
  • City of Rome
  • Clarion US 5526
  • Custodian
  • Dove US 6512
  • Edna (1866)
  • F. H. Prince
  • F.H. Prince US 120797
  • J.J. Carroll US 224735
  • James Buckley C 80910
  • James F. Cahill US 165740
  • John B Breymann US 91857
  • John J. Barlum (1890)
  • Jordan Beebe Jr. (1881)
  • Paddy Murphy
  • Queen Charlotte (1809)
  • Roberta US 110772
  • Rochester (Charles West) US 126115
  • Two Sisters (Twin Sisters) US 212527
  • United States (1835)
  • USS Ariel
  • USS Trippe (Contractor) (1802)
  • Waterloo (1840)
  • William F. Hallstead US 81414

Located but Unidentified

6
  • Jackie's Wreck
  • Mast Hoop Wreck (Bob Powell's Wreck)
  • Sailboat US 02947
  • The Cleveland Barge
  • Unidentified Hull – Barge
  • Unidentified Long Point

Lost (Still Missing)

2
  • Frontenac (1678)
  • Wyandotte (1833)

Pounded to Pieces

4
  • Annabell Wilson US 106475
  • H.H. Brown (1856)
  • James R. Benson (J. R. Benson)
  • Tonawanda US 24110

Recovered

1
  • Ashtabula (1906)

Scuttled

4
  • Alvah S. Chisholm Jr US 107557
  • Cape Horn US 4345
  • J. R. Worswick US 75993
  • William Edenborn US 81702

Storm

28
  • Agnes Barton (1853)
  • Albion (1848)
  • Ann
  • Arabian
  • Artic (Welland)(1858)
  • Birmingham 1843
  • C.B. Lockwood
  • Caspian (Lady Hillier, Isabella)
  • Charles F. Foster
  • Clough (1867)
  • Colonel Cook (Augusta)
  • Columbus (1835)
  • Commercial (1833)
  • Commodore Chauncey (1837)
  • Commodore US 125805
  • Edwin Harmon US 8190
  • G.M. Abell (John Young, George M. Abell & Able) US 10219
  • Gen. Tracy (Tracey)
  • General Burnside US 10163 (Quebec 1845)
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Maria Antoinette (1826)
  • Nehemiah Hubbard (1832)
  • Toledo (1836)
  • Toledo US 204831
  • W. D. Talcott (W.G. Tollcott)
  • W.A. Adair (1854)
  • Western Trader (1836)
  • William Case (The British Schooner Wm. Case)

Stranded/Grounded

16
  • Abbey (Abby)
  • America (1847)
  • Ashland (1844)
  • California (1846)
  • Canoppus(1855)
  • Eclipse US 7231
  • H.H. Brown (1856)
  • Jane Bell (1862)
  • Mautenee
  • Ontario (1810)
  • Philip D. Armour (1889)
  • Queen Victoria (1837)
  • Tecumseh (1845)
  • Uncle Sam (1833)
  • Utica (1846)
  • W.C. Richardson

Sunk/Foundered

52
  • Albion (1848)
  • Andes (1847)
  • Andrew (1826)
  • Annie Laurie (1874)
  • Artic (Welland)(1858)
  • Barge 43 US 172728
  • Barge NO. 4
  • Ceres (Gen. Houston) (1835)
  • City Of Painesville
  • Columbian
  • Columbian (1864)
  • Columbus (1835)
  • Comet (1826)
  • Commercial (1833)
  • Commodore US 125805
  • Concord US 4390
  • Cornell (Grace Danforth) US 86017
  • Dean Richmond
  • Eclipse US 7231
  • Edwin Harmon US 8190
  • Eli Bates (Ella Bates)
  • G.W. Clinton
  • General Burnside US 10163 (Quebec 1845)
  • George Dunbar (1867)
  • George J. Whelan (Erwin L. Fisher,Port de Caen,Bayersher,Claremont)
  • H.C. Thatcher (H.C. Thacher) US 42560
  • Honora Carr US 95851 (Maple Leaf)
  • Howard S. Gerkin (Rosamond Billett, T. P. Phelan) C 130272, US 140953, US 225429
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Industry?
  • John J. Boland Jr. (Tyneville) C 149467
  • M. O. Keys (1874)
  • Manzanilla C 85412
  • Margaret F. Biglow (1870)
  • Mast Hoop Wreck (Bob Powell's Wreck)
  • Nehemiah Hubbard (1832)
  • Oxford (1847)
  • Record H9889/80
  • S.K. Martin (City of St. Joseph)
  • Sailboat US 02947
  • Specular US 115876
  • Sweden (Pre-1845)
  • Uncle Sam (1833)
  • Unidentified Hull – Barge
  • Unidentified Long Point
  • Unidentified Sailboat
  • Union Jack
  • Valentine
  • W. D. Talcott (W.G. Tollcott)
  • Washington Irving
  • William Brewster (1838)
  • Young Zion

Wreck (Verified)

24
  • Antares US 366
  • Artic (Welland)(1858)
  • Birmingham 1843
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Caspian (Lady Hillier, Isabella)
  • Charles B. Hill
  • Clarion (1881)
  • Dean Richmond
  • Honora Carr US 95851 (Maple Leaf)
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Jackie's Wreck
  • Jordan Beebe Jr. (1881)
  • Kilarney
  • Mast Hoop Wreck (Bob Powell's Wreck)
  • Oxford (1847)
  • Record 1615
  • Record H9889/80
  • Record LS 1778/40
  • Record LS1777/40
  • Sailboat US 02947
  • The Cleveland Barge
  • Unidentified Hull – Barge
  • Unidentified Long Point
  • W.C. Richardson

Wrecked

23
  • Acme US 297
  • Amaretta Mosher
  • America (1847)
  • Charles H. Davis
  • Chicago (1848)
  • Chief Justice Marshall (1830)
  • City Of London US 126731
  • Clough (1867)
  • Clyde C 83141
  • Correspondent US 4370
  • Detroiter
  • G. P. Griffith
  • Gen. Tracy (Tracey)
  • Good Intent (1799)
  • H.H. Brown (1856)
  • Magnet (1856)
  • Moses and Elias (1834)
  • Quito US 6768 (David Ballentine)
  • Sacramento (1850)
  • Tecumseh (1845)
  • Timothy Baker. (Tim Baker, T. Baker) US 24156
  • W.R. Hanna C 26669
  • Walter Metcalf
  • Home
  • Docs
  • American Erie
  • Sunk/Foundered
  • Andrew (1826)

IDENTIFICATION & SITE INFORMATION

  • Vessel Name: Andrew
  • Type: Wooden Schooner
  • Builder: Bradford and Moses King
  • Year Built: 1826
  • Build Location: Gates, near Rochester, New York
  • Dimensions:
    • Length: 62 feet (18.9 meters)
    • Beam: 15 feet 6 inches (4.7 meters)
    • Depth: 5 feet 6 inches (1.7 meters)
    • Tonnage: 47 34/95 gross tons (old measurement)
  • Final Location: Near the lighthouse above the pier, Buffalo, New York, Lake Erie
  • Date of Loss: November 18, 1832
  • Coordinates: Not specified

VESSEL TYPE DESCRIPTION

The Andrew was a wooden Schooner rigged for lake navigation, designed for transporting cargoes across the Great Lakes. With a billet head and compact dimensions, it was well-suited for regional trade routes. Built with precision and care by Bradford and Moses King, the vessel was described as a “fine model,” showcasing the craftsmanship typical of early 19th-century shipbuilding on the Great Lakes.

HISTORY

Early Service:

The Andrew was launched in 1826 and initially enrolled in Buffalo, New York, under the ownership of its builders, Bradford and Moses King. Serving as a small cargo carrier, the Schooner primarily transported goods between ports on Lake Erie and neighboring waterways. Its size and construction made it reliable for short to medium-haul trips across the often unpredictable lake conditions.

Ownership Transfers:

In 1831, the Andrew was re-enrolled in Cleveland, Ohio, signaling a shift in its operational base. By the time of its loss in 1832, the vessel was owned by Captain Clifford Belden and captained by Captain McCloy.

Final Voyage and Wreck:

On November 18, 1832, the Andrew was bound for Buffalo, New York, carrying a cargo of lumber from Long Point, Ontario, Canada. As it approached its destination, the vessel encountered trouble near the lighthouse above the pier in Buffalo. It stranded and wrecked on the shoreline. While the exact circumstances leading to the wreck are unclear, the event marked the end of the Andrew’s operational life.

No loss of life was reported in the incident, and the vessel’s last registry document was surrendered in April 1833, annotated as “broken up,” signifying its official demise.

FINAL DISPOSITION

The Andrew was declared a Total Loss after its wrecking in Buffalo, New York, on November 18, 1832. The Schooner was broken up following the incident, with no salvageable remnants recorded in the historical records.

NOTMARs & ADVISORIES

Current Status: No Notices to Mariners (NOTMARs) are associated with the wreck of the Andrew. Its remains were likely salvaged or dispersed shortly after the incident.

LOCATED BY & DATE

The wreck of the Andrew is noted in historical records but has not been formally documented or located by modern underwater surveys.

CURRENT CONDITION & ACCESSIBILITY

The Andrew was broken up shortly after its wreck in 1832. Any potential remains have likely deteriorated or been buried under sediment near the Buffalo shoreline. The site is not documented as accessible for diving or exploration.

RESOURCES & LINKS

  • David Swayze Shipwreck File: Shipwreck Database
  • Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Historical Database
  • Bowling Green State University: Historical Collections of the Great Lakes

CONCLUSION

The Andrew’s brief operational history highlights the dynamic and often perilous nature of early maritime commerce on the Great Lakes. Built with care in 1826, the Schooner served as a key cargo transporter until its untimely loss in 1832 near Buffalo, New York. While its physical remains have faded, the Andrew’s story endures as a piece of Lake Erie’s rich maritime history.

Keywords:

Andrew, Lake Erie, Schooner, 19th Century Shipwreck, Buffalo New York, Maritime History, Bradford and Moses King, Great Lakes Shipping

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress