Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
  • American Seaway Project
  • Kingston Project
  • Verifed by Mark & Roman
  • Picton Project
  • Video Directory
    • Our 3D Models
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Blog
  • Shotline Diving – Master Wreck Index
  • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
  • Privacy Policy

St. Lawrence Seaway

8
  • Alexandria Bay
    • Grand View
    • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
    • Keystorm C 129749
    • Unknown Skiff
  • Cape Vincent
    • Benicia Boy
    • St. Louis – SLD Media
  • Clayton
    • Calumet Island Lifeboat
    • False Squaw

Abandoned

10
  • Alice G C 107169
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • City of St. Joseph (City of Chicago) US 126627
  • False Squaw
  • Grand View
  • Manhattan US 91905
  • Monarch
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Unknown Skiff
  • William P. Rend

Ashore

4
  • Advance US 365
  • Albany (1846)
  • Ariadne
  • Cambridge US 5399

Boiler Explosion

1
  • Challenge (1853)

Burnt at Dock

3
  • Bob Foote
  • Robert K
  • St. Louis – SLD Media

Collision

15
  • Albany (Orion) US 106306
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Chester B. Jones US 125159
  • Col. A.B. Williams
  • Comet (Mayflower) (1848)
  • Cora W Post C 83299
  • Dunderburgh US 6151
  • F.T. Barney
  • Glenorchy C 138213 (A.E. Stewart US 10778)
  • Grace A. Channon US 85309
  • Henry J. Johnson
  • New Orleans
  • Oliver Mowat C 92584
  • Silver Lake US 116263
  • Typo (1873)

Location

164
  • Lake Erie
    • Trade Wind (1853)
    • Dunkirk, New York
      • Annabell Wilson US 106475
      • Carlingford US 125024
      • Dean Richmond
    • Long Point
      • Crystal Wreck
    • Point Pelee & Island
      • Tioga US 24167
    • Rondeau, Ontario
      • C.B. Benson C 125226
      • Raleigh US 110154
      • William H. Stevens
  • Lake Ontario
    • Picton
      • Annie Falconer C 83285
      • Fabiola C 72577 (Royal Oak)
      • Katie Eccles C 75911
    • North of Main Duck
      • Olive Branch 3D Model
      • Oliver Mowat C 92584
    • Galloo Island
      • Northern Lights (1899)
      • Rover US 111150
    • Welland & St Catherines
      • Tiller Wreck
    • Amherst Island
      • City Of Sheboygan (C 104283, later cited C 137894)(US 125128)
      • Cornwall C 71609 (Kingston, Bavarian, Algerian)
    • Kingston
      • Aloha C 134264
      • Comet (Mayflower) (1848)
      • Cora W Post C 83299
      • Eureka C 46229. (US)
      • George A Marsh C 133750
      • HMS Princess Charlotte (HMS Burlington)
    • Garden Island
      • Hercules (1856)
  • Lake Huron
    • Challenge (1853)
    • Col. A.B. Williams
    • D.M. Wilson US 6772
    • F.B. Gardner US9198
    • Old Concord US 18923
    • Syracuse (1853)
    • Unidentified Thumb Wreck
    • Alpena, Michigan
      • Checotah (George D Russell) US 85267
      • Chickamauga US 127259
      • Lucinda Van Valkenburg US 14614
    • Bay City
      • City Of Detroit US 4378
      • Goliath
      • Kyle Spangler
      • Mary Alice B (Quintus, Bonanka, Lomax)
      • Nightingale US 18123
      • Racer
    • Presque Isle
      • American Union US 307
      • Defiance
      • L.M. Mason
      • Portland US 19623
      • Typo (1873)
    • Sarnia / Goderich
      • Ann Long (W.E. Gladstone) C 78026
      • Dolphin
    • Thunder Bay Marine Sanctuary
      • Barge No. 1 US 00070
      • Clifton (Samuel Mather)
      • Duncan City US 157096
      • Eliza H. Strong
      • Glenorchy C 138213 (A.E. Stewart US 10778)
      • Ishpeming US 100039
      • Monohansett (Ira H. Owen)
      • New Orleans
      • Newell A. Eddy
      • Northwestern (1847)
      • Ogarita
      • Oscar T. Flint
      • Typo (1873)
      • William P. Rend
    • Drummond Island
      • E.J. Laway Jr. US 212765
      • Monarch
    • Georgian Bay
      • Cyren1an C 77623
      • F.T. Barney
      • J. H. Jones C 90769
      • Jane Miller C 78022
      • W.L. Wetmore US 80196
    • Lexington
      • Dunderburgh US 6151
      • Eliza H. Strong
      • Glenorchy C 138213 (A.E. Stewart US 10778)
    • Point aux Barques
      • Albany (Orion) US 106306
      • Iron Chief
      • Philadelphia US 20142
    • Thumb Area Bottomland Preserve
      • Troy (1849)
  • Lake Michigan
    • C. D. Leuty
    • Colonel Ellsworth US 4354
    • Dan Hayes
    • Elva US 86059
    • Falcon (Kate Buttironi) US 14393
    • Grace Williams US 85882
    • Hetty Taylor US 95356
    • Industry US 202323 (C.H. Conover)
    • Keuka (A. Stewart and H.J. McAvoy) US 106644
    • Manhattan US 91905
    • Miztec
    • Niagara (1845)
    • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
    • Pride US 19681
    • Richard Winslow US 110003
    • Rouse Simmons US 110087
    • S.C. Baldwin US 23957
    • Sea Bird US 22368
    • Selah Chamberlain (1873)
    • Silver Lake US 116263
    • St. Albans US 23514
    • Vega US 161706
    • Vernon US 161557
    • Walter B. Allen US 26561
    • Walter L. Frost
    • Westmoreland
    • Milwaukee, Wisconsin
      • Transfer (William McGregor) US 80268
    • Port Sanilac
      • Algoma
      • Mary Alice B (Quintus, Bonanka, Lomax)
    • Sawtooth Reef
      • Grace A. Channon US 85309
      • Henry J. Johnson
    • Sheboygan
      • I. A. Johnson US 12090
      • Leviathan
      • Lottie Cooper US 140185
      • Newell A. Eddy
    • Straits of Mackinac Shipwreck Preserve
      • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
      • Eber Ward (1888)
      • Fred McBrier US 120452
      • Henry Clay 1842
      • James R. Bentley C 12720
      • Milwaukee (1852)
      • Unknown (False St. Andrew)
      • William H. Barnum
    • White Fish Bay
      • M.M. Drake US 91485
      • Success US 115376
    • Marquette Underwater Preserve
      • C. D. Leuty
      • Cambridge US 5399
      • Southwest US 22359
  • Lake Superior
    • Alfred P. Wright US 106539
    • Antelope (1861)
    • Niagara US 18714
    • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
    • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
    • Superior (1845)
    • Duluth, Michigan
      • Big Bay Sloop
    • Eagle River / Reef
      • James Pickands
    • Gargantua Harbor
      • Alta
      • Noquebay
    • Isle Royal
      • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
      • Henry Chisholm US 95610
    • Keweenaw Underwater Preserve
      • NIAGARA – 1873
      • Smith Moore
    • Michipicoten Island
      • Fedora US 120746
      • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
      • Hesper
      • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
    • Presque Isle
      • Charles J. Kershaw (Kershaw)
      • Portland US 19623
    • Sawtooth Reef
      • Bermuda US 2160
      • Colorado US 4267
    • White Fish Point
      • Chester B. Jones US 125159
      • Comet US 5683
      • Eureka US 8894
      • George Nester
      • Indiana
      • John M. Osborne
      • Panther C 138004
      • Pretoria US 150872
      • Robert Wallace
      • Sagamore US 57932
      • SS Myron (Mark Hopkins)
    • Point Au Sable
      • Kiowa
    • Ashland Wisconsin
      • Cambridge US 5399
      • James Pickands
      • Smith Moore
  • Other Lakes, Rivers and Quarries
    • Hercules (1917)
    • Minnetonka (Hopkins)

Fire

16
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Charles A. Street US 126485
  • Eliza H. Strong
  • F.B. Gardner US9198
  • Goliath
  • Hinckly
  • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
  • Manhattan US 91905
  • Montana US 90501
  • Niagara (1845)
  • Oscar T. Flint
  • Sea Bird US 22368
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • Tioga US 24167
  • Traveler (1852)
  • William H. Stevens

Pounded to Pieces

5
  • Annabell Wilson US 106475
  • Ariadne
  • Charles J. Kershaw (Kershaw)
  • City Of Grand Rapids US/C 125743
  • Montana US 90501

Scuttled

10
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Como
  • Cornwall C 71609 (Kingston, Bavarian, Algerian)
  • Duncan City US 157096
  • Excelsior (George)
  • Finn McCool
  • Hercules (1917)
  • HMS Princess Charlotte (HMS Burlington)
  • Minnetonka (Hopkins)
  • Transfer (William McGregor) US 80268

Final Disposition

115
  • Stranded/Grounded
    • American Union US 307
    • C. D. Leuty
    • Colorado US 4267
    • Falcon (Kate Buttironi) US 14393
    • Fedora US 120746
    • Forest City US 9914
    • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
    • Grand View
    • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
    • Hesper
    • James C King US 13871
    • James Pickands
    • Joesph S. Fay US 75315
    • Keystorm C 129749
    • Kiowa
    • M.M. Drake US 91485
    • Philo Scoville (Scoville, Philo – Midland Rover)
    • Racer
    • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
    • Walrus (Gray’s Reef Wreck)
    • Walter B. Allen US 26561
    • William H. Barnum
  • Sunk/Foundered
    • Albion
    • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
    • Algoma
    • Aloha C 134264
    • Arabia (1852)
    • Ava Bradley US 1910
    • Bermuda US 2160
    • C.B. Benson C 125226
    • Cayuga US 126556
    • City Of Detroit US 4378
    • City Of Sheboygan (C 104283, later cited C 137894)(US 125128)
    • Clifton (Samuel Mather)
    • Colonel Ellsworth US 4354
    • Crystal Wreck
    • D.M. Wilson US 6772
    • Dean Richmond
    • Dolphin
    • Emma Nielson (1883)
    • Eureka C 46229. (US)
    • Fabiola C 72577 (Royal Oak)
    • False Squaw
    • Fletcher
    • Genesse Chief
    • George A Marsh C 133750
    • Harriet B(Shenango No. 2, Pere Marquette 16, Muskegon) US 116695
    • Henry Chisholm US 95610
    • Hetty Taylor US 95356
    • HMS Anson ( L'Iroquosie)
    • Howard S. Gerkin (Rosamond Billett, T. P. Phelan) C 130272, US 140953, US 225429
    • I. A. Johnson US 12090
    • Indiana
    • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
    • Iron Chief
    • Ishpeming US 100039
    • J. H. Jones C 90769
    • Jane Miller C 78022
    • John & Alex (1924)
    • John M. Osborne
    • Katie Eccles C 75911
    • Keuka (A. Stewart and H.J. McAvoy) US 106644
    • Keystorm C 129749
    • Lottie Cooper US 140185
    • M. Stalker US 17211
    • Metropole (Sakie Shephard) US 115935
    • Milwaukee (1852)
    • Nelson US 18173
    • Niagara (1845)
    • Niagara US 18714
    • Nightingale US 18123
    • Northwestern (1847)
    • Old Concord US 18923
    • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
    • Peter W US 248805
    • Pride US 19681
    • Regina
    • Rouse Simmons US 110087
    • S.C. Baldwin US 23957
    • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
    • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
    • Southwest US 22359
    • Sport US 115152
    • St. Albans US 23514
    • Starrucca US 115381
    • Storm Spirit
    • Sweepstakes (1856)
    • Tiller Wreck
    • Trade Wind (1853)
    • Troy (1849)
    • Typo (1873)
    • Unknown (False St. Andrew)
    • Vega US 161706
    • Vernon US 161557
    • Walter B. Allen US 26561
    • Walter L. Frost
    • Wasaga (Wissahickon) US 80598
    • Westmoreland
    • William H. Barnum
  • Wrecked
    • C. D. Leuty
    • Colorado US 4267
  • Storm
    • Albion
    • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
    • Aloha C 134264
    • Annie Falconer C 83285
    • Barge No. 1 US 00070
    • Benicia Boy
    • City Of Sheboygan (C 104283, later cited C 137894)(US 125128)
    • Eureka C 46229. (US)
    • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
    • Jane Miller C 78022
    • Miztec
    • Nelson US 18173
    • Regina
    • Rouse Simmons US 110087

Tobermory Marine Sanctuary

9
  • Alice G C 107169
  • Arabia (1852)
  • City Of Grand Rapids US/C 125743
  • Forest City US 9914
  • James C King US 13871
  • John & Alex (1924)
  • Philo Scoville (Scoville, Philo – Midland Rover)
  • Robert K
  • Sweepstakes (1856)

Erie, Pennsilvania

3
  • Albion
  • Howard S. Gerkin (Rosamond Billett, T. P. Phelan) C 130272, US 140953, US 225429
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)

Wreck

30
  • Albany (Orion) US 106306
  • Ann Long (W.E. Gladstone) C 78026
  • Arabia (1852)
  • Ariadne
  • Bob Foote
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Challenge (1853)
  • Col. A.B. Williams
  • Dean Richmond
  • Dunderburgh US 6151
  • Excelsior (George)
  • F.B. Gardner US9198
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Grand View
  • HMS Princess Charlotte (HMS Burlington)
  • I. A. Johnson US 12090
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • John & Alex (1924)
  • Keuka (A. Stewart and H.J. McAvoy) US 106644
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Nightingale US 18123
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Oliver Mowat C 92584
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Panther C 138004
  • Silver Lake US 116263
  • Smith Moore
  • Tiller Wreck
  • Tioga US 24167
  • Walter B. Allen US 26561

IDENTIFICATION & SITE INFORMATION

  • Vessel Name: Eureka
  • Registry: Canadian Official Number 46229 (initially U.S.)
  • Rig: Schooner
  • Built: 1858, Wilson, New York, USA
  • Builder: J.W. Barnes
  • Hull Material: Wood

Dimensions:

  • •Length: 102 feet (31.1 meters)
  • •Beam: 24 feet (7.3 meters)
  • •Depth: 9.5 feet (2.9 meters)
  • Tonnage: 152 gross tons

Final Location: Lake Ontario, near Pigeon Island

Coordinates: N 44° 4.091’, W 076° 35.215’

Water Depth: 121 feet (37 meters)

VESSEL TYPE DESCRIPTION

The Eureka was a wooden Schooner designed with a sturdy Hull and tall masts, characteristic of mid-19th-century lake vessels. Initially serving as a general cargo transporter across Lake Ontario, the vessel was later adapted for the coal trade, a significant economic activity in the region during the late 1800s. Its robust construction and flexibility ensured it remained a valuable asset throughout its operational life.

HISTORY

Construction and Early Service:

The Eureka was built in 1858 in Wilson, New York, from locally sourced timber. It started as a general cargo vessel, navigating between the southern and northern shores of Lake Ontario. Initially registered in Lewiston, New York, the Schooner transitioned to Toledo, Ohio, in 1860, aligning with the growing demands of Great Lakes trade.

Ownership Timeline:

  • 1863: Owned by King & Steel, Toledo, Ohio.
  • 1864: Transferred to Giles & Sylvester, Montreal, Quebec.
  • 1874: Re-registered in Canada under William Nickle, Kingston, Ontario, transitioning to coal transportation.
  • 1876: Acquired by Williams & Co., Montreal, Quebec.
  • 1878: Owned by A. Cantin, Montreal, Quebec.
  • 1883: Final owners were Chambers & Chadwick, Kingston, Ontario.

Role in Maritime Commerce:

Initially a cargo vessel, the Eureka shifted to coal transport under Canadian ownership, connecting Kingston and Oswego, New York. This adaptation to market demands showcased the vessel’s importance in the Great Lakes’ economic ecosystem.

FINAL DISPOSITION

On November 26, 1883, the Eureka encountered a severe storm near Pigeon Island, Lake Ontario. The storm overwhelmed the vessel, forcing the crew to abandon ship. The Schooner sank shortly thereafter and now lies submerged at a depth of 121 feet.

CURRENT CONDITION & ACCESSIBILITY

The wreck of the Eureka rests in 121 feet of water, relatively well-preserved for a wooden vessel of its age. The site offers an opportunity to study mid-19th-century shipbuilding and the evolution of Great Lakes schooners. It is accessible to advanced divers familiar with deep and cold-water diving conditions. The wreck has been documented through photography and video surveys, adding to its historical significance.

NOTMARs & ADVISORIES

No specific Notices to Mariners (NOTMARs) are currently issued for the Eureka wreck site. However, divers should exercise caution, as the depth and water currents in the area can pose challenges.

RESOURCES & LINKS

  • •Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Comprehensive database of vessels like the Eureka.
  • •3D Shipwrecks:  Eureka wreck site.
  • •Great Lakes Ships: Archival information on the Eureka and similar vessels.
  • •Shotline Diving Video Survey: Documented video footage of the wreck.

3D Models – Eureka

Eureka by 3DShipwrecks on Sketchfab

The below show some of the steps taken to complete the model by Roger Lacasse

Eureka by Roger Lacasse on Sketchfab

Eureka Hull by Roger Lacasse on Sketchfab

Eureka by Roger Lacasse on Sketchfab

CONCLUSION

The Eureka exemplifies the adaptability and resilience of Great Lakes schooners during the 19th century. From general cargo transport to the coal trade, its operational history reflects the dynamic economic conditions of the era. Its sinking near Pigeon Island highlights the perils faced by sailors on Lake Ontario, even aboard robust vessels. Today, the Eureka stands as a valuable artifact, preserving the legacy of these iconic schooners and offering insights into the region’s maritime heritage.

KEYWORDS

Eureka shipwreck, Great Lakes schooners, Lake Ontario wrecks, 19th-century maritime history, Pigeon Island wreck, Great Lakes navigation.

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress