Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

26
  • A. H. Pitz US 2370
  • Adventurer US 107174
  • Alfred W. (1905)
  • Barge 115 US 53268
  • Bayline Park Wreck
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • Col. Ellsworth (c1850)
  • Dredge #8 C 116384
  • E. Cohen
  • Emerald (1862)
  • J. C. Keyes US 12710
  • Mary E. Mclachlan
  • Record 14974
  • Record 2352
  • Record 2352 Twin Barges
  • Record 2376
  • Record 3954
  • Record 4533
  • Record 7880
  • Robertson (Fayling) US 157127
  • Servia (1898)
  • Swansea US 115165
  • Tri-County Corridor Wreck
  • Unknown Motorboat
  • Unknown Shipwreck
  • Wayne US 80881

Ashore

36
  • A.C. Keating US 105346
  • Alex. Nimick US 106702 (Alexander Nimick)
  • Altadoc (Lake Shore) C 116577
  • Amboy (Helena)
  • Arthur Orr
  • Bessie Barwick
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • Charles E. Endell US 125773 (Star No. 2)
  • Chenango US 4335
  • City Of Bangor US 127131
  • Coaster (1848)
  • Eleanor (c1927)
  • F.L. Danforth US 17746
  • Florence Lester (1868)
  • Galatea (1882)
  • George (George Murray)
  • Golspie
  • Grey Eagle (1867)
  • J. C. Keyes US 12710
  • James Garrett US 13875
  • Julia Palmer US 145513
  • Keweenaw (1866)
  • L.C. Woodruff US 14609
  • Maplehurst C 138230 (Cadillac US 126876)
  • Missoula US 91928
  • Nirvana US 130481
  • Ozaukeem(1884)
  • Sarnian (B1895)
  • South West (1866)
  • T. M. Bradley US 145172
  • Transfer US 59353
  • Union US 25048
  • Unknown Motorboat
  • V.H. Ketchum US 25908
  • W.W. Arnold US 26166
  • William O. Brown US 26915

Burnt at Dock

22
  • A.F. Bartlett US 105130
  • Amethyst US 1712
  • City Of Winnipeg (Annie L. Craig)
  • Free Trade US 120588
  • Hiram R. Dixon US 107600
  • Josie Davidson US 76501
  • Mentor (1868)
  • Middlesex US 91307
  • Northern Dock & Dredge Scow No. 3 US 163490
  • Northern Dock & Dredge Scow No. 2 US 16489
  • Northern Dock & Dredge Scow No. 4 US 163491
  • Northerner (1871)
  • Roamer US 234923
  • Sachem US 116267
  • Sailor Boy US 116393
  • St. Ignace C 116191
  • Swansea US 115165
  • Thomas Quayle US 24159
  • Thomas W. Palmer (Samoa) US 145229
  • Thomas Quayle (1867)
  • W.H. Ritchie 1880
  • Winslow US 26174

Capsized

2
  • Golden Rule (1884)
  • Pathfinder (1895)

Collision

20
  • A.C. Maxwell (1870)
  • Charles J. Sheffield US 126414
  • Chester B. Jones US 125159
  • Donna Marie US 237994
  • Ellen Parker (1846)
  • Emma A. Mayes US 8722
  • Grace A. Channon US 85309
  • Henry J. Johnson
  • Huronton (Huron US 96425) C 141664
  • John B. Cowle
  • John Mitchell
  • Lyric US 140903
  • Marion L
  • Onoko US 155048
  • Oriole (1857)
  • Schuylkill US 115145
  • Shamrock US 46229 (John W. Hannaford)
  • T.T. Morford (1910)
  • Thomas Wilson (1892)
  • Violet G. C 138009

Destroyed at (Dock, Breakwater, Harbour)

7
  • A.C. Maxwell (1870)
  • Algonquin (1839)
  • Dawn (1888)
  • G.S. Weeks (1835)
  • Saveland (1873)
  • Schuylkill US 115145
  • Sparta US 121219 (Frank W. Hart)

Dismantled/Dynamited/Scrapped in Place

5
  • City Of Bangor US 127131
  • Lafayette
  • Lilly May (Lillie E, Lilly E) US 15872
  • Sparta US 121219 (Frank W. Hart)
  • St. Ignace C 116191

Explosion (Boiler, Gas, Dynamite)

4
  • Edward Gallagher (E. Gallagher, Ed. Gallagher) US 8220
  • Fred and Will US 9719
  • George Rogers (1889)
  • Thomas Quayle (1867)

Fire

40
  • A.F. Bartlett (1871)
  • Alice Vivian US 30240
  • Amethyst US 1712
  • Anna Ruth (American Favorite)
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Bob Anderson 1862
  • Carlotta US 105834 (Adrienne, Thora)
  • City Of Ashland US 126240
  • City Of Winnipeg (Annie L. Craig)
  • Commodore Jack Barry US 126355 (Constitution, Jack Berry)
  • Ella G. Stone (E.L. Mason)
  • Frank O’Conner US 76724 (Weston)
  • Geo. P. Savidge
  • Gordon Gauthier (1883)
  • Harvey Neelon C 73953
  • Hunter US 95471
  • Ira Chaffee US 12131
  • J.W. Eviston US 75723
  • James P. Donaldson (1880)
  • Jim Pullar (US 77146) C 126045
  • John Chassell (Echo) US 75352
  • Liberty US 141011
  • Mentor (1868)
  • Nellie Torrent US 130206
  • Northern Dock & Dredge Scow No. 1)
  • Prussia C 75638
  • Queen City US 20519
  • Queen of the Lakes US 20508
  • R.F. Goodman US 110546
  • Servia (1898)
  • SS Cumberland (1871)
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • T. M. Bradley US 145172
  • Tom Dowling US 24988
  • Traveler (1852)
  • V. Swain US 25888
  • V.H. Ketchum US 25908
  • W.J. Emerson C 107133
  • Winslow US 26174
  • Wood Island US 206510 (Lyle D.)

Located but Unidentified

3
  • Record 2385
  • Record 3343
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)

Lost (Still Missing)

4
  • Convair F-106 Delta Dart
  • F-106 Delta Dart
  • R. Hallaran US 110434
  • Steelvender US 223082

Pounded to Pieces

15
  • Allegheny (1873)
  • Charles J. Kershaw (Kershaw)
  • City Of Superior
  • Convair F-106 Delta Dart
  • F. Morrell (1866)
  • Gilbert Knapp US 10337
  • Golspie
  • John Jacob Astor (1835)
  • L.C. Woodruff US 14609
  • Laura Bell
  • Maplehurst C 138230 (Cadillac US 126876)
  • Plover (1857)
  • Sarnian (B1895)
  • W.W. Arnold US 26166
  • William O. Brown US 26915

Recovered

1
  • Freedom (Corona US 126850, James Bardon No. 7 US 76625

Scuttled

45
  • A.B. Conmee (Superior) US 80908
  • Beatrice M. C 107167
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Cormorant US 125334:
  • Curlew C 122178 (US 5965)
  • Eva Wadsworth US 8723
  • Gogebic (Green River) C 138863
  • Gravel King
  • Green River C 138863 (Gogebic)
  • Imperial (1902)
  • James P. Donaldson (1880)
  • Jed
  • Jed US 125590(Maplegrove, Cherokee)
  • Julian V. O’Brien US 76755
  • Mary Ann (Mary Ann of Dunnville) (1867)
  • Mary H. Boyce US 92033
  • Niagara C 53589 (Druid)
  • Oden US 155186
  • Record 4381
  • Robert L. Fryer (1888)
  • Robertson (Fayling) US 157127
  • St. Joe C 112007
  • Steven Selvick (Lorian, Cabot)
  • Theora US 145640
  • U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Mesquite
  • unknown 11 (Dipper Dredge)
  • Unknown 11 – Dipper Dredge
  • Unknown 12 (Dump Scow)
  • Unknown 12 – Dump Scow
  • Unknown 14 – Flat Scow
  • Unknown 15 – Flat Scow
  • Unknown 16 (Dipper dredge)
  • Unknown 17 (Tug)
  • Unknown 18 (Derrick scow)
  • Unknown 19 (Dump scow)
  • Unknown 3 (Flat Scow)
  • Unknown 4 (Dump Scow)
  • Unknown Dump Scow (No. 29)
  • Unknown Flat Scow (No. 31)
  • Unknown Tug (No. 26 – “J. Storey” listing)
  • Unknown Tug (No. 27)
  • Unknown 16 – Dipper Dredge
  • W.A. Rooth
  • W.G. Harrow (1893)
  • W.H. Ritchie C 130432 (Ritchie US 115729)

Shore Diving

2
  • Silver Harbour Conservation Area
  • Shore Dives Lake Ontario
    • Silver Harbour Conservation Area

Storm

34
  • A.A. Parker (1884) (Kasota)
  • Adella Shores (1894)
  • Alice Craig
  • Alice L US 208703
  • Annie M. Peterson (1874)
  • Arbutus C 92642
  • Atlanta US 106746
  • Barge 115 US 53268
  • Bertha Endress C 71229
  • C.F. Curtis (1900)
  • Canadian Government Ship (CGS) Lambton C 126409
  • Cleveland Pre-1852
  • Dot (ex‑Mary Merritt)
  • E.T. Carrington US 135211
  • Edmund Fitzgerald US 277437
  • Erie L. Hackley US 135615
  • Golden Rule (1884)
  • Henry B. Smith (1906)
  • J.L. Beckwith (James L. Beckwith)
  • Kakabeka
  • L.C. Waldo (1896)
  • Lord Selkirk’s Canoe Brigade (1816)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Olive Jeanette US 155181
  • Ozaukeem(1884)
  • P. S. Marsh
  • Sadie Thompson (1890?)
  • Sir Trevor Dawson(William C. Moreland)
  • SS Leafield (1892)
  • Steelvender US 223082
  • Sunbeam (1861)
  • SUSIE Q (1947, Fishing Tug)
  • Templeton (pre-1893)
  • Western Reserve US 81294

Stranded/Grounded

51
  • Agawa C 111807 (Robert P. Durham, Heron Bay, Federal Husky)
  • Algoma 1883
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Chandler J. Wells US 4274
  • Chenango US 4335
  • Chicago US 127590
  • City of Montreal
  • Colorado US 4267
  • Cris Grover (1878)
  • D & C
  • De Soto US 6441
  • E. Cohen
  • Elma US 8895
  • Emperor C 126654
  • F. Morrell (1866)
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Gale Staples (Caledonia)
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Grampa Woo US 8220
  • Gunilda
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • Hesper
  • Hunter US 95471
  • J. S. Seaverns (John P. Ward)
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • Jolly Inez (Turret Chief, Vickerstown) C106605
  • Kiowa (1920)
  • Lafayette
  • Maine US 16445
  • Manhattan (1867)
  • Marquette
  • Mary M. Scott US 16424
  • Mary Martini US 90978
  • Monarch C 96834
  • Ontario (1874)
  • Panama (John Craig)
  • Pasadena US 150465
  • Plover (1857)
  • Richard Morwood C 73952 (Lennie Powell, Montpelier)
  • Samuel H. Foster US 115150
  • Siskawit (1839)
  • Sitka
  • Spartan (1864)
  • St. Andrew (W.B. Hall) C 96094
  • Starucca US 115381
  • Stephen A. Douglas (pre-1850)
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • Tioga US 145405
  • Transport US 145211
  • Wellington US 26224
  • You Tell US 656020

Subject

5
  • Aircraft
    • Convair F-106 Delta Dart
  • Recovered
    • Edward C. Whalen C 134013 (John McLean,Adanac)
    • Freedom (Corona US 126850, James Bardon No. 7 US 76625
    • Pathfinder (1895)
  • Shore Dive
    • Silver Harbour Conservation Area

Sunk for a Breakwater or Dock

4
  • Charles Hebard
  • Julia Palmer US 145513
  • Maia (1898)
  • Spartan (1864)

Sunk/Foundered

97
  • A.A. Parker (1884) (Kasota)
  • Adella Shores (1894)
  • Alberta C 122177
  • America US 107357
  • Arbutus C 92642
  • Arlington (Glencadam, F.P. Jones) C 138210
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Bertha Endress C 71229
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Brandon C 92535
  • C.F. Curtis (1900)
  • Canadian Government Ship (CGS) Lambton C 126409
  • Cerisoles (1918)
  • Charles C. Griswold (1854)
  • Charles Horn US 92102
  • Chicago US 127590
  • City Of Ashland US 126240
  • Cleveland Pre-1852
  • Comet US 5683
  • Comrade US 34132
  • Cris Grover (1878)
  • David A. Wells US 6635
  • Dot (ex‑Mary Merritt)
  • Dredge #8 C 116384
  • Emma A. Mayes US 8722
  • Emporer C 126654
  • Erie L. Hackley US 135615
  • Frank O’Conner US 76724 (Weston)
  • Frank W. Wheeler US 120577
  • G.L. 37 US 165469
  • George T. Hope US 85800
  • George N US 202896
  • Glenlyon (William H. Gratwick, Minnekahtha)
  • Grampa Woo US 8220
  • Gunilda
  • Henry Steinbrenner
  • Hudson US 95953
  • Indiana
  • Ira H. Owen US 100410
  • J.H. Sheadle (1906)
  • Jessie Hall C 70288
  • Joesph Paige US 75593
  • John B. Cowle
  • John L. Gross US 13478
  • John M. Hutchinson US 75597
  • John M. Osborne (1882)
  • Judge Hart C 146247
  • Jupiter
  • Kellogg (1882)
  • Langham (Tom Adams)
  • Lizzie A. Law US 140133
  • Lord Selkirk’s Canoe Brigade (1816)
  • Maggie McRae C90697
  • Mediator (1862)
  • Moonlight US 90719
  • Myron (1888)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Niagara US 18714
  • Ocean Wave (1860)
  • Olive Jeanette US 155181
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Pacific
  • Panther C 138004
  • Pearl B Campbell US 150296
  • Phineas S. Marsh US 19679
  • R. Hallaran US 110434
  • R.F. Goodman US 110546
  • Rebel US 110083
  • Record 2352 Twin Barges
  • Reliable (1880)
  • Sadie Thompson (1890?)
  • Sagamore US 57932
  • Selden E. Marvin US 115771
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Sir Luke (1892)
  • Smith Mare
  • Sophia Smith (pre-1875)
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Southwest US 22359
  • SS Leafield (1892)
  • St. Andrew (W.B. Hall) C 96094
  • Steelvender US 223082
  • Stephen A. Douglas (pre-1850)
  • Sunbeam (1861)
  • Superior
  • SUSIE Q (1947, Fishing Tug)
  • T.H. Camp US 147127
  • Theano BR110350
  • Toledo US 24112
  • Unknown Tug (mini)
  • Urada 25243
  • W.J. Emerson C 107133
  • W.T. Chappell US 80642
  • Wahnipitae
  • Wasaga (Wissahickon) US 80598
  • William F. Sauber US 81317
  • Zillah (Edward Smith)

Wreck (Verified)

66
  • A. H. Pitz US 2370
  • Agawa C 111807 (Robert P. Durham, Heron Bay, Federal Husky)
  • Annie Sherwood US 310
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Bigler (J. Bigler, John Bigler)
  • Canadian Government Ship (CGS) Lambton C 126409
  • Carlotta US 105834 (Adrienne, Thora)
  • Cerisoles (1918)
  • Edmund Fitzgerald US 277437
  • Emporer C 126654
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Frank O’Conner US 76724 (Weston)
  • Frank W. Wheeler US 120577
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Gravel King
  • Gunilda
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • Howard (Admiral D.D. Porter)US 980
  • Indiana
  • J.L. Beckwith (James L. Beckwith)
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • John L. Gross US 13478
  • Langham (Tom Adams)
  • Lizzie A. Law US 140133
  • Mary Ann (Mary Ann of Dunnville) (1867)
  • Mediator (1862)
  • Monarch C 96834
  • Moonlight US 90719
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Panama (John Craig)
  • Panther C 138004
  • Peninsula
  • Puckasaw (John Hunsader)
  • Record 2352
  • Record 2352 Twin Barges
  • Record 2385
  • Record 3343
  • Record 3954
  • Record 4381
  • Record 4533
  • Record 6312
  • Record 7880
  • Sadie Thompson (1890?)
  • Saveland (1873)
  • Scotia US 115271
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Sir Trevor Dawson(William C. Moreland)
  • Sitka
  • Smith Moore (1880)
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • St. Andrew (W.B. Hall) C 96094
  • Starucca US 115381
  • Steven Selvick (Lorian, Cabot)
  • Superior (1845)
  • Thomas Wilson (1892)
  • Tioga US 145405
  • Traveler (1852)
  • U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Mesquite
  • Unknown 3 (Flat Scow)
  • Unknown Motorboat
  • Unknown Tug (mini)
  • Urada 25243
  • Wasaga (Wissahickon) US 80598
  • Western Reserve US 81294
  • You Tell US 656020

Wrecked

21
  • A.C. Keating US 105346
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Colorado US 4267
  • D.M. Clemson (1903)
  • De Soto US 6441
  • Eleanor (c1927)
  • Galatea (1882)
  • Howard (Admiral D.D. Porter)US 980
  • J.W. Bennett
  • J. C. Keyes US 12710
  • Keweenaw (1866)
  • Mary M. Scott US 16424
  • Mary Martini US 90978
  • Myron (1888)
  • Northrop F-89 Scorpion
  • Ontario (1874)
  • Phineas S. Marsh US 19679
  • Samuel H. Foster US 115150
  • Superior
  • W. L. Davis C 96811
  • William O. Brown US 26915
  • Home
  • Docs
  • Lake Superior
  • Stranded/Grounded
  • Mary M. Scott US 16424

MARY M. SCOTT (Wooden Canal Schooner)

Identification & Site Information

  • Name: Mary M. Scott (also recorded as Marien, May, Mary G., G. W. Scott)
  • Official Number: 16424
  • Built: 1857 by Otis DeWolf, Conneaut, Ohio
  • Dimensions: ~130 ft long × 26 ft beam × 11 ft depth; ~361 gross tons (Great Lakes Shipwreck Files, National Park Service)
  • Type: Wooden two-masted Canal Schooner
  • Cargo at Loss: Iron ore from Marquette (Facebook, National Park Service)
  • Date of Loss: November 2, 1870 (some sources list Nov 3) (Great Lakes Shipwreck Files)
  • Location: Went aground near Sand Point / Grand Island, Lake Superior; approximately 500 ft off Sand Point channel buoy in ~15 ft (5 m) of water (National Park Service)
  • Casualties: None reported (Midland Daily News)

Vessel Type & Function

A traditional 19th-century wooden Canal Schooner, built to carry bulk cargo such as iron ore, using sail power to navigate between ports like Marquette on Lake Superior down the canal systems.

Description

At ~130 ft, Mary M. Scott would have featured a full-bodied Hull appropriate for canal passage and heavy cargo. Loading iron ore for transport made her heavy-laden and susceptible to grounding in shallow coastal areas near points like Sand Point.

Circumstances of Loss

In early November 1870, the Mary M. Scott loaded with iron ore, grounded ashore near Sand Point or close to Grand Island. High autumn waves and shifting sandbars trapped and wrecked her Hull. The vessel broke up on the shoal, settling on her bottom (National Park Service).

Final Disposition & Wreck Site

  • Structure: Buried shallowly in shifting sands, with mostly bottom structure preserved.
  • Location: Located about 500 ft offshore, lying in roughly 15 ft (5 m) of water near the Sand Point buoy (NPS History).
  • Modern Status: Exposed by natural sand movement and visible to snorkelers and divers; considered a recreational dive site (National Park Service, National Park Service).

NOTMARs & Navigational Warnings

The Sand Point channel buoy marks nearby hazards. No formal Notice to Mariners specifically mentions the wreck, but local navigation charts caution about shallow wreckage and shoals.

Resources & Links

  • NPS – Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore diver information (National Park Service)
  • Wrecksite.eu entry summarizing build and loss (wrecksite.eu)
  • Great Lakes Shipwreck Files listing with technical specs and loss details (Great Lakes Shipwreck Files)
  • Baillod.com Munising area shipwrecks listing (baillod.com)

Conclusion & Dive Significance

The Mary M. Scott is a valuable shallow-water dive site in Lake Superior, offering visible Hull remains and cargo remnants. Despite its modest profile and burial, it offers historical insight into post-canal-era bulk transport. For underwater archaeologists and technical divers, it’s accessible and a tangible link to 19th-century maritime commerce on the Great Lakes.

Keywords & Categories

  • Region: Lake Superior (Grand Island / Sand Point)
  • Vessel Type: Canal Schooner
  • Cargo: Iron ore
  • Cause: Grounding (storm and shifting sandbar)
  • Dive Setting: Shallow (approx. 15 ft / 5 m); beginner-snorkel level

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress