Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

23
  • Calatco #2 US 236512 (U.S. Navy Tug No. 56, Leader)
  • Daniel G. Fort US 6627
  • Fox Island Steam launch
  • Frontier
  • Hattie L Johnson US 42513
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • Laurel (Laura)
  • Light Beacon
  • Mary E. Burgoyne US 17027 (Tempest)
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Record LS1775/40
  • Record LS1776/40
  • Rudder
  • Sacketts Harbour Wreck
  • Sodus Point 3
  • Sodus Point Bay Wrecks
  • Stoney Island Barge
  • The Craig Wreck
  • The Galloo Island Marine Railroad
  • Tonawanda Boiler
  • Triumph (1816)
  • Unidentified Hull – Webster NY
  • USS Sylph (1813)

Ashore

21
  • Acorn 1844
  • Albacore C 74380
  • Alice (1859)
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • C. G. Alvoord, Charles G. Alvord, California (1849) C 4389
  • Canada (1826)
  • Caroline Marsh
  • Carthaginian (1855)
  • Cayuga (1841)
  • Clyde C 33560
  • Commodore Owen
  • Fox Island Barge
  • George Clinton (1841)
  • J. S. Harvey
  • John Marshall
  • London C 72584
  • Norwegian and Tug Maria Melvin
  • Queen of the Bay
  • Sweet Home (1853)
  • Wide Awake
  • Williamson (pre-1761)

Buried by Landfill

1
  • Williamson (pre-1761)

Burnt at Dock

1
  • William Avery (1869)

Capsized

1
  • Anawan

Collision

9
  • Anna M. Foster (Foster ) C 71276
  • Carrier Dove (1854)
  • Commodore Barrie
  • Cuba
  • Fred McBrier (1881)
  • John Marsh
  • Nellie Wilder
  • Orcadian (1854)
  • Titania US 145074

Destroyed at (Dock, Breakwater, Harbour)

11
  • Ainsworth (1835)
  • Almira (1849)
  • Baltic US 2138
  • Birmingham (Alciope United Kingdom)
  • City Of Toronto
  • Eliza K. Redford US 135493
  • George B. Sloan
  • George M Chapman (1854)
  • Thrush C 97200
  • Tranchemontagne (1864)
  • Tuscarora C 80912

Explosion (Boiler, Gas, Dynamite)

1
  • Ray Bay Wreck

Fire

14
  • Dalhousie (1869)
  • Ellen Bronson (1835) (Eton Bronson)
  • Ellswerth
  • Geneva US 86005
  • Hinckly (1902)
  • HMS George
  • HMS Halifax
  • HMS Mohawk
  • HMS Oswego
  • HMS Vigilant
  • United Workman US 164181
  • William Avery (1869)
  • William Gardner
  • Wisconsin (1852)

Located but Unidentified

13
  • Canal Boats Near Oswego
  • Galloo Island Wreck #2
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • K2
  • Mystery Steamer
  • Nipigon (Maplehill, Maplegrange) C 130272
  • Oswego 2
  • Oswego 6
  • Oswego D24
  • Record LS1775/40
  • Sacketts Harbour Wreck
  • Unidentified Hull – Webster NY
  • Unknown Sloop

Lost (Still Missing)

9
  • General Atomics MQ-9A Reaper
  • Getaway Gertie
  • HMS George
  • HMS Halifax
  • HMS Mohawk
  • HMS Ontario
  • HMS Oswego
  • HMS Vigilant
  • Wisconsin (1852)

Pounded to Pieces

7
  • Addie Membery US 106360
  • Alliance 1856
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • Caroline Marsh
  • Dolphin (pre 1819)
  • Dominion (1867)
  • Tuscarora C 80912

Recovered

1
  • Anawan

Scuttled

8
  • HMS George
  • HMS Halifax
  • HMS Mohawk
  • HMS Ontario
  • HMS Oswego
  • HMS Vigilant
  • Nipigon (Maplehill, Maplegrange) C 130272
  • Tekakwitha

Storm

18
  • American (1870)
  • Anawan
  • Annandale C 72572
  • Belle Adkins (Belle Atkins)
  • Canal Boats Near Oswego
  • City of New York C 116393 US 4377
  • Comorant US 240399 (Russell 4)
  • Dredge Gordon
  • HMS Ontario (1780)
  • Homer Warren (Atlantic)
  • John Burt US 75300
  • Mary Kay (Payday II)
  • Ocean Wave (1868)
  • Pigeon (pre 1876)
  • Saint Peter (1873)
  • Washington (Lady Washington)
  • Wave Crest C 83414
  • Young America US 27515

Stranded/Grounded

16
  • Charleston (1837)
  • Clara Hill US 125753
  • Cortez
  • Fair American (1804)
  • Hattie L Johnson US 42513
  • Isabella H. (Mccormick)
  • J.B. Collins
  • John P. Hale (1856)
  • Mary Kay (Payday II)
  • Minerva Cook
  • Rochester 1
  • Sparta/David W. Mills
  • Triumph (1816)
  • Wellington (pre-1854)
  • York (1799)
  • Young America US 27515

Sunk/Foundered

142
  • 104m Wreck
  • 117m Wreck
  • 118 fathoms Wreck
  • 137m Wreck
  • 62 Fathoms Wreck
  • Appelona (1814)
  • Ardelia (1835)
  • Atlas (1838)
  • Auburnville C 177428 (W.A.C. No.5)
  • Black Duck US 2115
  • Boston (1847)
  • Brothers (pre-1845)
  • Burt Barnes C 150489
  • Canal Boats Near Oswego
  • Cargo Barge
  • City of New York C 116393 US 4377
  • Commodore Barrie
  • Comorant US 240399 (Russell 4)
  • Daggerboard Schooner (Old Taylor or Galloo?)
  • Dredge Gordon
  • E. Hall (1864)
  • E.B. Gannett US 7243
  • E.J. Vickery
  • Etta Belle US 8730 (Champion)
  • Fishing Boat (Boston Whaler 21ft)
  • Foam (1845)
  • Foley US 6749
  • Frank C Barnes (J.C. Osgood US 120894) C 116386
  • Fred L. Wells US 120246 (Raney)
  • Galloo Island Wreck #2
  • H.B Preston (1877)
  • H.B. US 96862
  • H.R. Preston (1877)
  • Hamilton J. Mills US 42662
  • Harbourfest Houseboat
  • Henry Doville (H. Dovell, Doveil)
  • Hiawatha C 96904
  • HMS Charity
  • HMS Ontario (1780)
  • Homer Warren (Atlantic)
  • Iceberg (1856)
  • Iona C 94922
  • Jeska C 126128
  • John Marsh
  • John P. Hale (1856)
  • John S. Parsons US 76999
  • K11
  • K13
  • K2
  • K21
  • K4
  • K6
  • K8
  • Lady of the Lake
  • Laura C 17234
  • Light Beacon
  • Lochiel (Three Seas)
  • London (1848)
  • Lydia Ann (pre-1867)
  • Madison
  • Malta (1871)
  • Mary Ballard (1855)
  • Mary Kay (Payday II)
  • Matilda Taylor
  • Meteor C 33569
  • Mid Lake
  • Mid Lake 2 Wreck
  • Mid Lake 3
  • Mid Lake 4
  • Mid Lake 5
  • Milan (1845)
  • Milwalkee (1872)
  • Napoleon (1833)
  • Nellie Brown US 18318 (Neptune)
  • Nellie P. Downey
  • Nellie Wilder
  • Nisbet Grammer
  • Nonesuch
  • Ocean Wave (1868)
  • Onondaga C 80913
  • Ontario (Bay State)
  • Orcadian (1854)
  • Oswego 10
  • Oswego 2
  • Oswego 3
  • Oswego 4
  • Oswego 5
  • Oswego 6
  • Oswego 7
  • Oswego 8
  • Oswego 9
  • Oswego D11
  • Oswego D15
  • Oswego D17
  • Oswego D20
  • Oswego D21
  • Oswego D24
  • Oswego D27
  • Oswego D30
  • Oswego D32
  • Oswego D34
  • Oswego D36
  • Oswego D4
  • Oswego D44
  • Oswego D6
  • Oswego D9
  • Philip Becker U74214
  • Pigeon (pre 1876)
  • Plow Boy(1816)
  • Pulaski 1
  • Pulaski 2
  • Queen Of The Lakes C 77626
  • Ray Bay Wreck
  • Rochester 2
  • Rochester 3
  • Rochester 4
  • Rochester 5
  • Rochester 6
  • Royal Albert (1858)
  • Rudder
  • Shannon (1867)
  • Sodus Point 1
  • Sodus Point 2
  • Sodus Point 3
  • Sodus Point Yacht
  • Sophia
  • State of Ohio
  • Stowell (pre1862)
  • T.J. Waffle C 130767
  • Tekakwitha
  • Three Friends (1864)
  • Tip Top US 59171
  • Twilight (1858)
  • Unidentified Border Wreck
  • Unidentified Schooner
  • Unidentified Steamer
  • Unknown Sloop
  • William Elgin (Catherine)
  • William John (1844)
  • William Preston US 26563
  • Wisconsin (1852)
  • Wreck 7

Wreck (Verified)

104
  • 104m Wreck
  • 117m Wreck
  • 118 fathoms Wreck
  • 137m Wreck
  • 62 Fathoms Wreck
  • Anna M. Foster (Foster ) C 71276
  • Appelona (1814)
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • Atlas (1817)
  • C-45 Expeditor (Model 18 Twin Beech)
  • Canal Boats Near Oswego
  • Comorant US 240399 (Russell 4)
  • Cortez
  • Daggerboard Schooner (Old Taylor or Galloo?)
  • Daniel G. Fort US 6627
  • Dauntless C 64967
  • Dredge Gordon
  • E.B. Gannett US 7243
  • Fishing Boat (Boston Whaler 21ft)
  • Fox Island Barge
  • Fox Island Steam launch
  • Galloo Island Wreck #2
  • H.B Preston (1877)
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • Hiawatha C 96904
  • Ireland C 30791
  • John Marshall
  • K11
  • K13
  • K2
  • K21
  • K4
  • K6
  • K8
  • Lehigh Valley Railroad Trestle
  • Light Beacon
  • Malta (1871)
  • Mary Kay (Payday II)
  • Mid Lake
  • Mid Lake 4
  • Mid Lake 5
  • Milwalkee (1872)
  • Mystery Steamer
  • Nipigon (Maplehill, Maplegrange) C 130272
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Ocean Wave (1868)
  • Orcadian (1854)
  • Oswego 10
  • Oswego 2
  • Oswego 3
  • Oswego 4
  • Oswego 5
  • Oswego 6
  • Oswego 7
  • Oswego 8
  • Oswego 9
  • Oswego D11
  • Oswego D15
  • Oswego D17
  • Oswego D20
  • Oswego D21
  • Oswego D24
  • Oswego D27
  • Oswego D30
  • Oswego D32
  • Oswego D34
  • Oswego D36
  • Oswego D4
  • Oswego D44
  • Oswego D6
  • Oswego D9
  • Plow Boy(1816)
  • Pulaski 1
  • Pulaski 2
  • Queen Of The Lakes C 77626
  • Ray Bay Wreck
  • Record LS1775/40
  • Record LS1776/40
  • Roberval C 125972
  • Rochester 3
  • Rochester 4
  • Rochester 5
  • Rochester 6
  • Sacketts Harbour Wreck
  • Sodus (pre1876)
  • Sodus Point 1
  • Sodus Point 2
  • Sodus Point 3
  • Sodus Point Bay Wrecks
  • Sophia
  • Stoney Island Barge
  • Tekakwitha
  • The Craig Wreck
  • Tonawanda Boiler
  • Tornado
  • Unidentified Border Wreck
  • Unidentified Hull – Webster NY
  • Unidentified Hull – Sacketts Harbour
  • Unidentified Schooner
  • Unidentified Steamer
  • Unknown Sloop
  • Washington (Lady Washington)
  • Waterson Point Wreck
  • Wreck 7

Wrecked

17
  • Agnes Hope C 71168
  • Cabin Aircraft 1935
  • Cessna 172 N737TH
  • Dauntless C 64967
  • F-101B-105-MC Voodoo/58-0268
  • Frank Stewart (pre1863)
  • Frontier
  • HMS Charity
  • James G. Blaine US 20195 (Pensaukee)
  • James H. Shrigley US 76214
  • London C 72584
  • Maggie Hunter (John S. Clark) C 72954
  • Robert Bruce (pre-1835)
  • Thomas R. Merritt US 72212
  • Wayne
  • Williamson (pre-1761)
  • Young America US 27515
  • Home
  • Docs
  • American Ontario
  • Sunk/Foundered
  • Meteor C 33569

Identification & Site Information

  • Vessel Name: METEOR
  • Type: Wooden Schooner
  • Builder: S. Little, Wilson, New York
  • Year Built: 1856
  • Official Number: C33569 (under Canadian registration)
  • Tonnage: 61 tons
  • Length: Not documented
  • Beam: Not documented
  • Depth: Not documented
  • Final Location: Approximately 4 miles off Oswego, Lake Ontario
  • Coordinates: Not provided
  • Depth of Wreck: Unknown

Vessel Type Description

The METEOR was a two-masted wooden Schooner, designed for carrying bulk goods across the Great Lakes. Built in 1856, it exemplified the durable and versatile construction of mid-19th-century schooners, which played a vital role in the burgeoning Great Lakes trade network. With a modest tonnage of 61, the METEOR was suited for transporting commodities like wheat, lumber, and other goods between ports.

History

Early Service and Ownership

The METEOR was constructed by S. Little in Wilson, New York, and initially served under his ownership. It carried various cargoes across Lake Ontario, a key waterway for commerce during the mid-19th century. The Schooner saw multiple changes in ownership, moving from American to Canadian registration in 1862 when sold to a Canadian owner. Over its operational lifetime, it was owned by individuals and firms including D. Parmentier, McNelly & Hicks, and Hunt & Co.

Notable Incidents

  • Cargo Damage (1860): The METEOR suffered wheat cargo damage, an early challenge in its career.
  • Collision with KATE HINCHMAN (1866): A significant incident occurred when the METEOR collided with another Schooner off Oswego. Despite the collision, the METEOR remained operational.

Final Voyage and Loss

On April 12, 1874, the METEOR embarked on a voyage from Oakville, Ontario, bound for Ogdensburg, New York, with a cargo of 2,500 bushels of wheat. Caught in a severe storm near Oswego, the vessel Foundered and sank approximately four miles offshore. The crew managed to escape and were rescued by the Steamer MILWAUKEE. The Total Loss of the METEOR was estimated at $2,200.

Legal Aftermath

The sinking of the METEOR became the focus of a legal dispute in the case of “Brown v. The British American Assurance Company.” The owner, F.J. Brown, had canceled an insurance policy and attempted to insure the Schooner with a different company. Unbeknownst to him, the vessel had already sunk. The court ruled in Brown’s favor, stating that the cancellation was invalid as the insurer knew of the vessel’s loss before Brown. Brown was awarded $1,940 in damages from a $2,000 policy.

Final Disposition

The METEOR sank in 1874, marking the end of its service. The exact wreck location remains undetermined, and the depth is unknown. The vessel’s sinking was listed in the maritime casualty records for that year, leaving behind a tale of resilience, trade, and tragedy.

Current Condition & Accessibility

The wreck of the METEOR has not been located, and no diving or exploration efforts have been documented. Given the age of the wreck and its wooden construction, it is presumed to be in a state of significant deterioration, if any remnants remain.

Resources & Links

  • Great Lakes Ships: Detailed records of vessels operating on the Great Lakes.
  • Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Comprehensive information on Great Lakes shipwrecks and maritime activities.
  • David Swayze Shipwreck File: A database of shipwrecks with detailed records of the METEOR and other vessels.

Conclusion

The METEOR, a Schooner constructed for trade on the Great Lakes, had a robust career marked by challenges and resilience before its ultimate loss in 1874. Its story, culminating in a dramatic legal case, highlights the hazards of 19th-century maritime commerce and the legal complexities surrounding shipwrecks. The METEOR remains a significant part of Lake Ontario’s maritime history.

Keywords

METEOR, Schooner, Great Lakes Shipwreck, Lake Ontario, Oswego, 19th-Century Maritime History, Cargo Transport, Wheat Trade, Maritime Casualties.

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress