Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

2
  • Algomah
  • Mackinaw Skiff

Ashore

2
  • J.E. Shaw (1854)
  • Muskingum US 16413

Burnt at Dock

1
  • W.G. Fox (1912)

Capsized

1
  • Victor (1867)

Collision

4
  • Cedarville (A.F. Harvey)US 226492
  • Fred McBrier (1881)
  • M. Stalker (1863)
  • Maitland

Fire

2
  • B.W. Arnold US 3333
  • Remora (1883)

Lost (Still Missing)

1
  • Bark Black Warrior (Black Maria)

Pounded to Pieces

1
  • D. N. Barney (1844)

Storm

3
  • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
  • Colonist
  • Milwaukee Belle US 16642

Stranded/Grounded

5
  • A. L. Abbell ( C. L. Abell)(1855)
  • Nightingale us 18123
  • Rollo US 208819
  • White Swan US 222237
  • William H. Barnum (1873)

Sunk/Foundered

16
  • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
  • Anglo Saxon C 71213
  • Flying Dutchman US 37297
  • Genesse Chief (1846)
  • HMS Welcome
  • M. Stalker US 17211
  • Milwaukee (1852)
  • Milwaukee Belle US 16642
  • Minneapolis (1873)
  • Robert Burns US 21177
  • Thomas Kingsford (1856)
  • Uganda US 25289
  • Uncle Sam US 25131
  • Unknown (False St. Andrew)
  • William H. Barnum (1873)
  • William Young US 26230

Wreck (Verified)

7
  • Cedarville (A.F. Harvey)US 226492
  • Eber Ward (1888)
  • Mackinaw Skiff
  • Milwaukee (1852)
  • Robert Emmett
  • Sandusky (1848)
  • Unknown (False St. Andrew)

Wrecked

3
  • Guide US 10319
  • Nightingale us 18123
  • Victor (1867)
  • Home
  • Docs
  • Straits of Mackinac Shipwreck Preserve
  • Storm
  • Milwaukee Belle US 16642

Identification & Site Information

  • Name(s): Milwaukee Belle
  • Official Number: 16642
  • Year Built: 1854
  • Place Built: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
  • Final Location: Off Brevort, Michigan, Straits of Mackinac, Lake Michigan
  • Date Lost: 18 November 1886
  • Cause of Loss: Dismasted in storm, drifted northeast, sank
  • Final Cargo: Lumber

Vessel Type

Wooden-hulled, two-masted Schooner built for cargo service across the Great Lakes, primarily transporting bulk goods such as lumber and Railroad Iron.

Description

  • Hull Material: Wood
  • Length: 133.9 ft (40.83 m)
  • Beam: 28.4 ft (8.66 m)
  • Depth: 9.4 ft (2.87 m)
  • Tonnage (Old Style): 368 6/95 tons
  • Decks: 1
  • Builder: James M. Jones
  • Original Owner: D. Newhall
  • Home Port (1884): Chicago, Illinois

History

  • 1854: Enrolled in Milwaukee, WI; suffered leakage transporting Railroad Iron; repaired in Cleveland.
  • 1856–1860: Experienced multiple collisions and weather-related incidents, including a notable grounding in a gale near Cheboygan, MI, and being salvaged by the Tug Leviathan.
  • 1861–1864: Involved in another collision that resulted in the sinking of Schooner Great Western; jettisoned cargo (30 tons of lead) in 1863.
  • 1865–1880s: Underwent major repairs including new arches, knees, frame, and decks. Rebuilt in 1871.
  • Owners: Transitioned from D. Newhall to Norris & Davis (Chicago), J.D. Gardner (Milwaukee), C.S. Gardner (Chicago), E.E. Ayers (Chicago), and finally Powers (Chicago).
  • Collisions: Documented in 1857 (with J.C. Riggs) and 1860 (with C.H. Walker, W.H. Craig, and Arcturus) during dense traffic in the St. Clair River.
  • 1886 Loss: Dismasted during a severe storm, drifted northeast, and ultimately sank near Brevort, MI. Gear and rigging were later salvaged.

Final Disposition

The vessel was destroyed in a gale after losing masts, with its wreck going down in Lake Michigan. Salvage crews recovered portions of the rigging and equipment, but the Hull was not raised or reused.

Located By & Date Found

No records found confirming discovery or precise location of wreckage.

NOTMARs & Advisories

None noted.

Resources & Links

  • Buffalo Commercial Advertiser (1857, 1860, 1861) – Incident reports
  • Buffalo Daily Republic (1857, 1860) – Collision details
  • Buffalo Morning Express (1860) – Collision summary
  • U.S. Merchant Vessel Lists (1884) – Tonnage and registration
  • Great Lakes Maritime Database – Enrollment and ownership history

Conclusion

The Milwaukee Belle represents a typical mid-19th-century Great Lakes Schooner—built for versatility, often refitted and repurposed, and eventually succumbed to the cumulative effects of age and storm damage. Her career spanned over three decades of active service, making her loss emblematic of the challenges faced by wooden freight vessels on Lake Michigan.

Keywords, Categories, Glossary Terms

  • Schooner, wooden Hull, storm loss, Lake Michigan, cargo ship, 19th-century shipwreck, Straits of Mackinac, marine collision, salvage, Great Lakes schooners

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress